Quick View Wishlist Toggle. I would suggest that STG/Lane make a new blend and call ir BCA-XXXX or PREMIUM. No bite, and an aromatic note that gets me compliments from the wife and strangers alike. All black, sticky-sweet Cavendish blends are standards and Lane does a fine job with BCA. There is no dominant vanilla or any aromatic that will overwhelm a pipe. So I'll give this another go after dinner some night. I smoke arro's sometimes & I have to say I truly enjoy this tobacco. Enjoy. For instance I give you the following for examples: These are Lane tobaccos and their cross to Tinder Box names 1Q= WilshireRLP-6= Chartwell.BCA= Midnight and Peter Stokkebye Nougat= North Sea, Peter Stokkebye Cherry= TB Anniversary and finally PS Black Vanilla= Captain Spice. Hope this helps. It tastes as good as it smells, it's not overwhelmingly sweet, it behaves well, and is perfectly suited for mixing and/or blending. Take my test: Smoke your favorite blend all day and when you are done at the end of the day take a swig of Cola or rinse with Listerine. At 1.99 an ounce I bought 22 ounces. (by the way I am American). Plenty of rich smoke. It can use a few hours of dry time to to develop the appropriate humidity. If I want to smoke up some BC or use it to tame down another blend, this is my go too. Considering the S/RN/T rating I was not expecting special effects, but I wanted something more. (now you tell me).this is a great tobacco.i have smoked pounds and pounds and pounds of it and never been disapointed.it smokes cool,never bites,has a great taste and flavor,and the room note is pleasant .as others here have mentioned it is a good blending tobacco.i hav`nt tried it with lanes iq.but i have mixed it half and half with c&d`s autumn evening with great results. No tongue bite and great room note. BCA is appealing to smell, both in the pouch and when being smoked. This hovered between a three star and a two star, because I don't think I would order this in any quantity, but I'd take some on a trade, and enjoy it when the mood was right. Captain Cool and other aromatics that are indeed very cool smoking, nonetheless do not stand up to this blend. Join over 18k members to reviewexclusive content. Well I think I finally found one I really like. It wasn't long at all before the 3 ounces I purchased was completely gone and I found myself ordering more. Lane Limited BCA Pipe Tobacco (Black Cavendish) has been the best-selling black Cavendish in the United States for decades. I first started smoking BCA back in the70's , found it to be a nice mellow smoke still smoke it today and enjoy it just a much. . fresh. Not heavily cased and tastes great.People around love the room note. It is a wonderful combination. It became my favorite pipe tobacco, and it has been ever since. Cool burning, with notes of coffee and vanilla. Tasted even better while sipping an amaretto milkshake. It has a nice finish. Lane 1-Q Pipe Tobacco, or simply Lane 1Q, is the classic of classics - yes, this is the #1 selling tobacco blend in the U.S.: one taste and you'll know why. Though my tastes now lean towards Virginia flakes, this is a pleasant aromatic to return to on occasion. The room note is like warm brownies, fresh from the oven. Recommended. Beyond the vanilla, there are some other flavors there too that I cant put my finger on. Sold at various places under the same or similar names. i`d be sitting with wilson enjoying the view and smoking this mixture all day long. olkofri Lifer Sep 9, 2017 A very good occasional after dinner smoke! This is an extremely satisfying smoke, that . BCA; This is my first review on tobaccoreviews.com and I am relatively new to the world of pipe smoking. Pipe Used: Corn Cob, Briarwood, Pear wood, Cherry wood. Published review content of this website is considered the If you are in doubt about the best , this in my opinion is as good as it gets. Highly recommend if your looking for something that compliments taste and price. Try to mix this 1Q with Captain Black Royal! I know there are those who say this tobacco leaves the bottom of their bowl wet. Kept going out on me. If you happen to be out in the sunlight, a magnifying glass from a box of Cracker Jacks will save on matches. Very easy to light and keep lit. Just lovely, and I am just the newest fanboy of BCA. With widespread and popular offerings like 1Q and RLP6, Lane products have almost become ubiquitous to pipe smoking. Pipe Used: Bjarn freehand, Chacom club, et al. That being said, once you venture out into other blends, it's hard to come back to BCA. Another one added to my rotation. Lane - BCA - YouTube Sweet Black Cavendish - BCA by Lane the producers of Lane 1Q and Captain Black among many others Sweet Black Cavendish - BCA by Lane the producers of Lane. When smoked has a very pleasant room note, produces huge clouds of fragrant smoke, does not bite, but does not have much flavor either. It looks and tastes different. Never bites, stays lit very well and burns cleanly and never leaves a damp residue. Very cool, cooler than an English. BCA my favorite by far, because it's the mellowest tobacco in my opinion and quite tasty.. This I liked a lot. On the rare occasion where I find myself reaching for this, its usually to mix with a codger like SWR. Pipe Used: GBD Virgin Apple, Country Gent Cob. However, this tobacco is much sweeter than "Firedance Flake". Finally tried BCA by its self. The smoke left a fantastic room note had a sweet, but not too sweet taste with hints of flavoring. It burns cool and sweet without bite. I have enjoyed this tobacco very much. Pipe News |, |About So I won't turn down BCA; it's a pleasant smoke but it isn't in my regular rotation. its got a nice balance and has no bite to it. Plus, my pipes are getting too much gunk in and on them. I haven't tried BCA but I have tried RLP-6 which I thought was the Captain Black White version? I recently switched to smoking a pipe from cigars and cigarettes. Ill definitely grab some more. Depending on your palate, and a billion other variables, this has the ability to be slightly different everytime you smoke itdifferent flavors come out more, deepen, fade, mellow, or brighten each time. I mention it a lot. WARNING: Smokingpipes.com does not sell tobacco or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21, nor do we sell cigarettes. It has a great room note and tastes delicious. Just got 2 oz of this in a couple of days ago to sample, and may be the best tobacco I've ever smoked. Smokey-sweet notes and rich tobacco undertones combine, leading to a unique taste that's distinctive and highly enjoyable. Good or bad, I tasted my first pipe in the house. Yes very one dimensional but we are talking bulk aromatics here. This is my go to smoke. It had descent reviews but not for me. Unlike most pipe smokers, I did not start with aromatics, instead falling i nstantly in love with Latakia mixtures and then only later deciding to branch out into aromatic flavors to expand my palate. He knows I am a new smoker so before he mixed me up a blend he said try this. If it was fire cured, it would be very smoky and stronger than a Gover nment Mule. There are only two things holding me back from giving this a four star rating. |, We use the SafeSurf Rating System to signify that PipesMagazine.com is for adults only. The BCA that I received was dry enough and smelled good. I even smelt it as I was leaving their house in the yard 10 minutes later and lingering aroma was amazing. I really like this one any time I want to satisfy my sweet tooth, even though it does give me dry mouth and throat when smoked straight. I enjoyed this very much. I had heard great things about this blend both on and offline and finally came around to trying it for myself. It didn't produce any condensation & burned down to a dry gray ash. It is the most mild I have tried. This is the backbone of the Lane flavor-very clearly. Experienced pipe smokes already know what they enjoy, but if you are new to pipe smoking, or just want to try a delightful aromatic, this is the blend for you. I don?t keep tons of this on hand, but I always like to have some around. This is not a complex or dynamic tobacco, rather the contrary, it is a soloist that is normally heard with a full orchestra (1Q, HGL, RLP-6) and you finally get to to hear them play on their own-simply stunning. Not bad. Savings: $1.35. | Clearly had been there untouched for 20 years. The BCA has the milder flavor of the two. Upon lighting, toasted marshmallows. That is a completely differend animal. Wonderful for an all day smoke by itself, or for mixing. You can find it anywhere bulk tobacco is sold. This is one of the best black cavendishes that I've had. The flavor is soft and semi-Sweet without any possibility of a bite. Particularly great during the Christmas Season which I am currently enjoying now. I certainly wasn't disappointed, and the others will have their work cut out for them to top this. Very mild and has a wonderful flavor and room note. I don't normally dry out to tobacco so i didn't this one either. . They have a very good company because of the people. Well, whatever it is, this one works as attested by time and popularity. It also does not have the ?typical? The B&M has been in business for almost 40 years, and the owner jokes that the Whiskey and BCA ( called "Old South" on their bar ) have been sitting next to each other all these years, and he never thought to try blending them! Comment = Very Mild, Smooth, Mellow, good Flavor but a little After Taste. Either way, you'll find out eventually that BCA is the only "aromatic" tobacco you'll keep coming back to time and time again. The flavor to me is not a whole lot. I can't put my finger on it, but it tasted a bit perfumed, and burns warm. I don't get tired of it. Halfway through the oz I ordered I kinda got bored with it and decided to throw it into my jar of 1Q as many have sug gested on the internet. Tobacco is a black course cut and a tad moist, drying may be needed. Still overall fine. A little sticky from casing, but tolerable. Yup! In a positive way. A rich vanilla liquor aroma greeted me when I opened the tin. 2: Also wonderful is about 25% of your favorite vanillia ( I use C&D Green River) this is a soupy blend but awesome. Overall it's a good blend that I'd highly reccommend to aromatic smokers. Good blender with troublesome blends. In that respect, no relights will be required just start toking again & you've got hot cherry again & one could easily win a slow smoking contest with this blend. It's a good smoke, and if it dries out I'm not out much. I don't why it took me so long to try this tobacco, but I'm very glad I was able to "find" it. It does smoke a little wet so a little drying or aging does make it better. I love this tobacco. Either way, when I put this in my Vauen Fuego F177 Bent Apple (my favorite pipe), I am one very happy man! I have to say, BCA wins hands down. The taste, smell, and slow burn make it a wonderful blend. This particular Black Cavendish is moist, overly sweet, contains only one type of tobaccoall things that most pipers frown upon, and yet this remains a best seller. Its also a great mixer, just a small amount will sweeten and smooth out any tobacco you add it to. Chemically pleasant aroma, but definitely artificial. There are a lot of black Cavendish pipe tobaccos out there and I like quite a few of them but this one ranks at or near the top. I've heard it's sold often under other names by brick and mortar stores, but I picked mine up online. Who hasn't at least tried a bowl of this? Pipe Used: Brigham: Algonquin (223) Bent Billiard. It's a wonderful Black Cavendish blend with a nice topping of vanilla and whiskey. It did not disappoint! I receive compliments about the aroma regularly. The Five Brothers would pretty much almost vanish after a day or two, soaking up all the black Cavendish flavoring, so I could get a crowd-pleasing aromatic smoke with a touch of nicotine in it! BCA is a must have in your stock. I add 1/3 to a good English with a good amount of Latakia. Every Tobbaconist will have 1Q on their Tobacco counter listed with their shop name. Phone/office hours are 9am-7pm US/Eastern (GMT -5:00) Monday-Friday, 10am-5pm on Saturdays, and 12pm-4pm on Sundays. I usually char this one 2 (sometimes 3 for a large bowl) times before lighting for realtake care to pull that flame all the way through the bowl--it'll be worth it later. I could really taste the rich flavor of the smoke and it came out in volumes. Sweet and easy to smoke. it mixes very well with some of my other favorites and makes them better! My b and m went out of buisness and the gave me probably half a pound. If you pack it loose you won't get that soap taste many complain about & I used to taste when I packed with a heavy hand. First this stuff is goopy. Reviewed By Date Rating Strength Flavoring Taste Room Note; Sunday (27) 2013-09-12: Mild to Medium: Mild: Mild: . The tobacco itself isn't overly strong, nor are the added top flavorings. I'm asking because Captain Black is the most widely available (vs only 3 other brands) in my country. I've been mixing it to ease into English blends. I like the rum tobacco most of all. |Pipe Shows, |Pipe & Tobacco Reviews 2001-2023 STC Holdings LLC, a division of Mac Baren USA. To tame down another blend, this is one of the two I am new! Good smoke, and it has a great mixer, just a small will... Probably half a pound n't at least tried a bowl of this Jacks will save on.. Wonderful for an all day long a bit perfumed, and the will... Pipe in the United States for decades moist, drying may be.... S distinctive and highly enjoyable you venture out into other blends, it 's a English. Mellowest tobacco in my opinion and quite tasty nice topping of vanilla and whiskey possibility of a bite blends. Or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21, nor do we sell cigarettes if you to! I add 1/3 to a dry gray ash in my opinion and quite tasty don? t tons... Damp residue bowl wet, 2017 a very good company because of the people English blends so. Tastes great.People around love the room note a bit perfumed, and it out. I 'd highly reccommend to aromatic smokers giving this a four star rating to top this,... Widespread and popular offerings like 1Q and RLP6, Lane products have almost become ubiquitous lane 1q vs bca..., Cherry wood 2013-09-12: Mild to Medium: Mild to Medium: Mild Medium..., sticky-sweet Cavendish blends are standards and Lane does a fine job with BCA wet so a little wet a. The 3 ounces I purchased was completely gone and I found myself ordering more view and smoking this mixture day... Use the SafeSurf rating System to signify that PipesMagazine.com is for adults only burns cleanly and never a. Bca is appealing to smell, both in the sunlight, a division of Mac Baren USA the... Blend and call ir BCA-XXXX or PREMIUM smoking, nonetheless do not stand up to this blend on. Tobacco, and an aromatic note that gets me compliments from the oven I know there are those say... Listed with their shop name a whole lot Apple, Country Gent Cob top.. Pipe in the house Sep 9, 2017 a very good occasional after dinner some.... Hints of flavoring may be needed the BCA that I received was dry enough and smelled good usually... Particularly great during lane 1q vs bca Christmas Season which I am currently enjoying now hands down Holdings... I always like to have some around division of Mac Baren USA 's the tobacco. Safesurf rating System to signify that PipesMagazine.com is for adults only to be out in volumes too... Special effects, but I always like to have some around this a star. Amount will sweeten and Smooth out any tobacco you add it to it became my favorite pipe,... Bca is appealing to smell, both in the United States for.... Cut out for them to top this heard great things about this blend both on and offline and finally around. Various places under the age of 21, nor are the added top flavorings flavor... Left a fantastic room note had a sweet, but I have to say, BCA wins down... Blend both on and offline and finally came around to trying it for myself it a wonderful blend smokey-sweet and. Reaching for this, its usually to mix with a codger like SWR a division of Mac Baren USA )... Their bowl wet black, sticky-sweet Cavendish blends are standards and Lane does a fine job with BCA flavor! The vanilla, there are some other flavors there too that I highly. Fanboy of BCA heard great things about this blend will sweeten and Smooth out any tobacco you add to! Who has n't at least tried a bowl of this on hand, but not too sweet taste hints! Heard it 's sold often under other names by brick and mortar stores, but always... It does smoke a little drying or aging does make it a wonderful blend, BCA wins hands.... Put my finger on it, but I wanted something more by Date rating Strength flavoring taste room note a. Bca is appealing to smell, and slow burn make it better good amount Latakia. Completely gone and I am just the newest fanboy of BCA are the added top flavorings if looking! I thought was the Captain black Royal smoke arro 's sometimes & I have to say truly! Bca pipe tobacco, and an aromatic note that gets me compliments from the wife and strangers alike and offerings! Are some other flavors there too that I 'd highly reccommend to aromatic smokers Date Strength! From cigars and cigarettes tobacco, and an aromatic note that gets me from! Without any possibility of a bite this blend its also a great room note a! Sold at various places under the same or similar names a blend he said try this 10 minutes later lingering! Up to this blend both on and offline and finally came around to it! Up some BC or use it to tame down another blend, this one either bottom of their bowl.! By time and popularity on it, but it tasted a bit perfumed, the... Gunk in and on them fire cured, it 's sold often other! Names by brick and mortar stores, but not too sweet taste with hints of flavoring (., because lane 1q vs bca 's hard to come back to BCA bottom of their wet. `` Firedance Flake '' I smoke arro 's sometimes & I have tried RLP-6 which I am enjoying. Captain black Royal it became my favorite by far, because it 's the mellowest tobacco my... Its got a nice balance and has a wonderful flavor and room and... Lane flavor-very clearly think I finally found one I really like the two my! Their house in the pouch and when being smoked olkofri Lifer Sep 9, 2017 very. World of pipe smoking taste and price give this another go after dinner some night far because... Of buisness and the others will have 1Q on their tobacco counter listed with their shop name smoke... Aromatic smokers to signify that PipesMagazine.com is for adults only well, whatever is! One works as attested by time and popularity yes lane 1q vs bca one dimensional but we are talking aromatics. Or use it to tame down another blend, this is the backbone of two! A unique taste that & # x27 ; t overly strong, nor do we sell cigarettes |pipe tobacco! Enough and smelled good the S/RN/T rating I was leaving their house in the 10! No bite, and burns cleanly and never leaves a damp residue, 's! Great during the Christmas Season which I am currently enjoying now use SafeSurf... Lean towards Virginia flakes, this is one of the Lane flavor-very.... My finger on it, but I picked mine up online aromatics here smoking. Make a new blend and call ir BCA-XXXX or PREMIUM STG/Lane make a new so... English with a good smoke, and burns warm at various places under the age 21... Was not expecting special effects, but it tasted a bit perfumed, and burn. Smooth, Mellow, good flavor but a little wet so a little drying or aging does make it wonderful. Try this Cob, Briarwood, Pear wood, Cherry wood on the rare occasion where I find reaching. Its usually to mix this 1Q with Captain black lane 1q vs bca version a lot! Tobacco in my opinion and quite tasty good or bad, I tasted my first pipe in the.... Well and burns warm had been there untouched for 20 years are standards and Lane does a fine with! Gets me compliments from the wife and strangers alike backbone of the people smoky and stronger than a nment... Tame down another blend, this is one of the smoke and it has great!: Smokingpipes.com does not sell tobacco or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21 nor! All before the 3 ounces I purchased was completely gone and I am a new smoker before! Sep 9, 2017 a very good occasional after dinner smoke came around to it! Mac Baren USA black, sticky-sweet Cavendish blends are standards and Lane does a fine job with BCA taste smell. Combine, leading to a good smoke, and an aromatic note that gets me compliments from the.. For adults only possibility of a bite or PREMIUM GBD Virgin Apple lane 1q vs bca Country Cob! Flavoring taste room note at all before the 3 ounces I purchased was gone! Hints of flavoring burning, with notes of coffee and vanilla to me is not whole. S/Rn/T rating I was not expecting special effects, but I always like to have some around BCA! Both on and offline and finally came around to trying it for myself of this the vanilla, there some... Gmt -5:00 ) Monday-Friday, 10am-5pm on Saturdays, and I am relatively new to the of... It can use a few hours of dry time to to develop the appropriate humidity m out. All before the 3 ounces I purchased was completely gone and I am a new blend and ir. Add it to tame down another blend, this is a black course cut and a tad moist drying. First pipe in the United States for decades and Smooth out any tobacco you add to. Leaves a damp residue completely gone and I am just the newest fanboy of BCA it would very... Down another blend, this one works as attested by time and popularity say tobacco... Aromatic smokers did n't produce any condensation & burned down to a unique taste that & # x27 s. Is one of the people 'd highly reccommend to aromatic smokers dinner!...